San Jose State University - Anthropology
SOCIETY FOR APPLIED ANTHROPOLOGY
Department of Anthropology
University of North Carolina at Greensboro
Institute for Learning Innovation
SOCIETY FOR APPLIED ANTHROPOLOGY
SOUTHWESTERN ANTHROPOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION
Human Relations Area Files
SOUTHWESTERN ANTHROPOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION
Research Consultant
Institute for Learning Innovation
San Jose State University
San Jose
CA
Graduate Coordinator
Department of Anthropology
Southwestern Anthropological Association (SWAA)
Southwestern Anthropological Association (SWAA)
Southwestern Anthropological Association (SWAA)
The Journal of Ethnology (China)
Editorial Board Member
Chengdu
Sichuan
China
San Francisco Bay Area
Associate Professor of Anthropology
San Jose State University
Vice President
Southwestern Anthropological Association
English
Spanish
Italian
President’s Outstanding Emerging Scholar Award
Western Social Science Association
San Jose State University
San Jose
CA
Assistant Professor of Anthropology
San Jose State University
Collaborate in research design for a multi-site study of social networks and wellbeing in disaster-affected communities and disaster-induced resettlements in highland Ecuador. Manage fieldwork team in Ecuador
design and administer social network and structured interviews
conduct key informant interviews
collect archival data
develop and manage project database
and collaborate in data analysis.
Department of Anthropology
University of North Carolina at Greensboro
Research Consultant
Collect archival data on livestock-related violence in northwestern Kenya and adjacent territories and plot violent cases in GIS. Retrieve and plot rainfall
landform
elevation
and hydrology data in GIS and perform spatial analyses to test study hypotheses regarding the spatial distribution of livestock-related violence.
Human Relations Area Files
Graduate Research Assistant
Collaborate in research design for a multi-site study of social networks and wellbeing in disaster-affected communities and disaster-induced resettlements in Mexico. Administer social network and structured interviews
collect archival data
develop and manage project database
and collaborate in data analysis.
Department of Anthropology
University of South Florida
North Carolina State University
The Journal of Ethnology (China)
Raleigh
North Carolina
Post-doctoral Research Fellow
North Carolina State University
Ph.D.
Concentrations: Anthropology of Development
Forced Displacement and Resettlement
Disasters
Latin America\n\nDissertation: Reciprocity and Political Power in Disaster-Induced Resettlements in the Ecuadorian Andes
Applied Anthropology
University of South Florida
Economic Anthropology
Cultural Anthropology
Organizational Studies
Urban Anthropology
Ethnographic Methods
Anthropology of Latin America
Environmental Anthropology
Graduate Seminar in Anthropological Theory
M.A
Concentrations: Urban Anthropology
Poverty Studies\n\nThesis: Neoliberalism and Community Organizing for Affordable Housing
Applied Anthropology
B.A
Anthropology
Lambda Alpha National Collegiate Honor Society for Anthropology\n\nThree-time recipient of The Antoinette Bigel Endowment for Student Research in Anthropology
Participant Observation
Program Development
Survey Design
Proposal Writing
Anthropology
Grant Writing
Research Design
Teaching
University Teaching
GIS
Quantitative Research
Research
Cultural Anthropology
Ethnography
SPSS
Qualitative Research
Social Network Analysis
Focus Groups
Program Evaluation
Field Work
Disaster Resettlement Organizations and the Culture of Cooperative Labor in the Ecuadorian Andes
This paper explores the role of cooperative labor groups (mingas) in the political economy of disaster-induced resettlements in the Andean highlands of Ecuador and how these groups play important roles in the distribution of aid and development resources. I look at the ways in which the resettlement agencies and other institutions have worked with minga groups and highlight power relations implicated in the forms of brokerage that are produced in this encounter. In these contexts
mingas become globalized as extensions of state and multinational processes of disaster mitigation
resettlement
and development. The story that unfolds here is not so much about how the cultures of social groups are changed by the interventions of state and multinational institutions
but instead how these encounters are brokered by often powerful intermediaries whose ability to compete for scarce resources is intimately tied to institutional strategies.
Disaster Resettlement Organizations and the Culture of Cooperative Labor in the Ecuadorian Andes
While social network analysis continues to enjoy considerable attention
literature on social network data collection often lacks explicit attention to methods. This presents special challenges to approaching the problems of undertaking social network analysis and of studying disaster preparedness
planning
and
ultimately
risk reduction. In this paper
we address this issue by presenting our synthesis of several strategies for network analyses from our processes for network identification and data collection in a longitudinal study of multi-jurisdictional
inter-agency wildfire response networks in the American Northwest. In the course of this ongoing project
the process of detecting and collecting data on pre-existing and emergent networks in the real world was not a matter of one theoretical or empirical judgement
but rather several. We alternated between: (1) spatio-ecological detection of jurisdictions adjacent to areas at-risk for large wildfires; (2) a hybrid approach to selecting actors and agencies identified as common participants in wildfire response networks; and (3) event-based detections of parties to specific wildfire response networks. We conclude with steps for thinking through network identification and bounding
integrating networks
conceptualizing rosters and ties in initial and events-based phases
and how to manage longitudinal network data collection.\n
Methodological considerations in pre- and post-emergency network identification and data collection for disaster risk reduction: Lessons from wildfire response networks in the American Northwest
Hugo Yepes
Arthur D. Murphy
Linda M. Whiteford
Chris McCarty
Graham A. Tobin
Eric C. Jones
Issues of Gender and Sexual Orientation in Humanitarian Emergencies: Risks and Risk Reduction (Springer series on Humanitarian Solutions in the 21st Century)
This study delves into women's roles in disasters exploring how gender and its relationships to well-being
mental health
and physical health face distinctive challenges in different social networks. A social network framework was employed in nine disaster-affected and resettled communities in Ecuador
Mexico
and the United States to better understand how gender and social support interact to impact resilience. Over 500 people
affected by Mt. Tungurahua (central Ecuador)
Mt. Popocatépetl (south central Mexico)
landslides in the Caribbean coastal mountains (central Mexico)
and several hurricanes (eastern United States) participated in lengthy interviews. Data were collected on household demographics
health traits
and social interactions. \n\nResults show that
in the non-resettled sites
network structure was much more relevant for individual well-being than in the resettled sites—the latter of which displayed high comorbidity with physical health and other stress measures—indicating that structure of social networks are indeed upset by resettlement and no longer predictive of well-being in a resettlement context. Although important variation exists between contexts
we found that perceived support from family or spouse (but not friends)
and having a network that is well-connected but not dense were protective factors for women
but that providing emotional support to others was a negative factor
as was having a higher percentage of women in one's network
and giving. We also explore other similarities
as well as differences between sites. The interplay of personal networks and gendered well-being following disasters helps further our understanding of the dynamics of vulnerability and thus should be considered when looking at mitigation strategies
community sustainability and resilience.
Articulation of Personal Network Structure with Gendered Well-Being in Disaster and Relocation Settings
Linda M. Whiteford
Graham A. Tobin
Eric C. Jones
The concept of social networks has been invoked in forced displacement and resettlement research and policy for nearly two decades. The concept is drawn upon in applied research to foster the development of resettlement policies intended to avoid destroying ‘social capital’ by preserving social networks (Cernea 1996a
2004). However
we hope to build upon prescriptions for maintaining “tightly-knit kin groups” (Cernea 1988:7) and “established integrated communities” (Cernea 1996a:305) where individuals act “around common interests” (Cernea 1997:1575)
by exploring the implications of a wider variety of social structures present in both pre- and post-resettlement communities. In this brief paper
we build a case for an approach to forced displacement and resettlement that is both relational and structural
which we expect to prove critically explanatory both of the disarticulation of community life in resettlement and of the still broader structures within which local relations are constituted and situated. This is followed by a brief introduction to a set of basic data collection and analysis techniques. We conclude with a concise review of the practical and theoretical advantages afforded by this approach.
Critical Aspects of Social Networks in a Resettlement Setting
Linda M. Whiteford
Graham A. Tobin
Arthur D. Murphy
Eric C. Jones
Although virtually all comparative research about risk perception focuses on which hazards are of concern to people in different countries—regardless of whether they have directly experienced a hazard or disaster or not—much can be gained by focusing on predictors of the level of concern in particular countries and places. The comparative approach helps us carefully explore how people experience and think about extreme events by giving attention to the country in which a given event occurs
and by investigating how relevant factors play out in a specific place. In this case
we examine social network predictors of risk perception in a total of six sites among victims of a flood in Mexico (one site)
and volcanic eruptions in Mexico (one site) and Ecuador (four sites). We conducted over 450 interviews with questions about the danger people feel now about what happened
their current concerns
and regarding their expectations about the future. We explore how aspects of the context in which people live have an effect on how strongly people perceive natural hazards in relationship with demographic
well-being
and social network factors. Generally
our research indicates that levels of risk perception for past
present and future aspects of a specific hazard are similar across these two countries and six sites. However
these contexts produced different predictors of risk perception—in other words
there was little overlap between sites in the variables that predicted the past
present or future aspects of risk perception in each site. Generally
current stress was related to perception of past danger of event in Mexico sites
but not in Ecuador sites; network variables were mainly important for perception of past danger (rather than future or present danger)
although specific network correlates varied from site to site across the countries.
Cross-Cultural and Site-Based Influences on Demographic
Well-being
and Social Network Predictors of Risk Perception in Hazard and Disaster Settings in Ecuador and Mexico
This paper presents a study of an Andean form of cooperation
the minga
in a disaster-affected community and a disaster-induced resettlement – both due to volcanic eruption – in the Andean highlands of Ecuador. I explore factors affecting the continuity of minga practice post disaster and reveal some of the largely temporal tensions between wage labor and minga practice. However
I argue that much of the variation in inter-household minga participation was due to interventions by the state and NGOs and how these organizations structured the labor and temporal organization of mingas as a form of discipline. I further find that this dynamic is an extension of the historical role mingas have played in domination and local agency and highlight how this has important implications for disaster recovery at the household and community levels and for disaster relief and resettlement policy and practice.\nKey words: cooperation
resettlement
disaster
NGOs
Ecuador
Enduring Cooperation: Time
Discipline
and Minga Practice in Disaster-induced Displacement and Resettlement in the Ecuadorian Andes
Disaster capitalism is typically defined as a systematic and opportunistic reconfiguration of economies and economic regulations in service of capitalist interests under the cover of environmental crisis. This article offers another complementary variety of disaster capitalism—the production of capitalist subjects
petit capitalists “empowered” by the state and nongovernmental organizations via initiation into the special knowledge and crafts of small enterprise. This is at once a well-intentioned strategy and ne that reveals the limits of neoliberal imagination—the inability to envision recovery but through individualistic
entrepreneurial endeavors. In my study of recovery from the eruptions of Mt. Tungurahua in Ecuador
I present cases of state and nongovernmental organizations providing aid and recovery to affected highland peasants. These projects reveal people being moved to assume certain subjectivities by limited “inventories of possibility” and an internalization of dominant norms and structures. Even as subjects posture their culture and practices as moral
communitarian alternatives to capitalist greed
local economic strategies took on entrepreneurial characteristics that articulated with neoliberal ambitions of state and global institutions; peasant ambitions and desires are produced and invoked as if they were locally derived
while at the same time being co-constituted by dominant interests. I discuss how these dramas unfold
with attention to the creative agency exercised by locals.
Petit capitalisms in disaster
or the limits of neoliberal imagination: Displacement
recovery
and opportunism in highland Ecuador
Sun Lei
Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to determine whether it is useful to tease apart the intimately related propositions of social production and social construction to guide thinking in the multidisciplinary study of disasters.\n\nDesign/methodology/approach: The authors address our question by reviewing literature on disasters in the social sciences to disambiguate the concepts of social production and social construction.\n\nFindings: The authors have found that entertaining the distinction between social production and social construct can inform both thinking and action on disasters by facilitating critical exercises in reframing that facilitate dialog across difference. The authors present a series of arguments on the social production and construction of disaster and advocate putting these constructs in dialog with vulnerability frameworks of the social production of disasters.\n\nOriginality/value: This commentary contributes to disambiguating important theoretical and practical concepts in disaster studies. The reframing approach can inform both research and more inclusive disaster management and risk reduction efforts.
Social production of disasters and disaster social constructs
This article introduces the special issue of The Annals of Anthropological Practice on “Continuity and Change in the Applied Anthropology of Risk
Hazards
and Disasters.” After reviewing the factors that account for the heightened anthropological attention to disasters in the early 21st century
I review each of the contributions to the special issue. The topics included in the special issue represent some of the simultaneously perennial and currently pressing issues in the anthropology of risk
hazards
and disaster: vulnerability
resilience
culture change
culture in practice
risk reduction
disaster capitalism
and response and recovery. The objective of this special issue is to help provide an orientation to the theoretical and applied tools that will help anthropologists better prepare to assist in disaster contexts. It will assist those that may be encountering these issues for the first time
as well as those already working in disaster-affected communities. [risk
hazards
disaster]
Continuity and Change in the Applied Anthropology of Risk
Hazards
and Disasters
Julie Maldonado
Marshaling the American Anthropological Association’s UN Observer Status
we attended the 2017 Global Platform in Cancun
Mexico
where we interviewed dozens of practitioners about the role of culture in disaster risk reduction
while documenting and analyzing discussions
formal statements
and official documents of the multiple parties to the event. Our goals were to (a) theorize how culture becomes discursively constructed and enacted in disaster risk reduction programs; and (b) meet practitioners who could elucidate the moments when institutional mandates and community goals diverge
where the cultures of aid and of the affected are out of sync
and to find out what they do when that happens.
What Can We Learn from Practitioners’ Stories?
This article provides a brief introduction to advancements in the anthropology of disasters as well as the historical antecedents and the intellectual collaborations that contributed to contemporary work in the field. It reviews the multiple directions
methodological approaches
and theoretical leanings that comprise today’s diversified field of disaster anthropology and discusses how the monographs included in the special edition of Human Organization (74[4]) on the applied anthropology of risks
hazards
and disasters showcase the variety of topics and themes engaged by applied anthropologists who work on disaster-related issues.\n\nKey words: risk
hazards
disaster
culture
displacement
climate change
Applied Anthropology of Risk
Hazards
and Disasters
Arthur D. Murphy
Graham A. Tobin
Linda M. Whiteford
Eric C. Jones
The devastating eruptions of Mount Tungurahua in the Ecuadorian highlands in 1999 and 2006 left many communities struggling to rebuild their homes and others permanently displaced to settlements built by state and nongovernmental organizations. For several years afterward
households diversified their economic strategies to compensate for losses
communities organized to promote local development
and the state and nongovernmental organizations sponsored many economic recovery programs in the affected communities. Our study examined the ways in which gender and gender roles were associated with different levels and paths of access to scarce resources in these communities. Specifically
this article contrasts the experiences of men and women in accessing household necessities and project assistance through formal institutions and informal networks. We found that women and men used different types of informal social support networks
with men receiving significantly more material
emotional
and informational support than women. We also found that men and women experienced different challenges and advantages when pursuing support through local and extralocal institutions and that these institutions often coordinated in ways that reified their biases. We present a methodology that is replicable in a wide variety of disaster
resettlement
and development settings
and we advocate an inductive
evidence-based approach to policy
built upon an understanding of local gender
class
and ethnic dynamics affecting access to formal and informal resources. This evidence should be used to build more robust local institutions that can resist wider social and cultural pressures for male dominance and gendered exclusion.
Gendered Access to Formal and Informal Resources in Postdisaster Development in the Ecuadorian Andes
In the study of disasters
the concept of vulnerability has been primarily employed as a cumulative indicator of the unequal distributions of certain populations in proximity to environmental and technological hazards and an individual or group ability to “anticipate
cope with
resist and recover” from disaster (Wisner et al. 2004). This concept has influenced disaster research as a means to question how natural
temporary
and random disasters are and focused analysis on the human-environmental processes that produce disasters and subject some populations more than others to risk and hazards. Critics also point out that vulnerability frameworks elude measure
strip people of agency
and reify stereotypes of the Global South. In light of both the historical importance and the sustained critiques of the concept
this chapter looks to anthropological and related literature to explore several questions: is it possible that vulnerability has outlived its usefulness? Is it still analytically meaningful for anthropologists currently working in the area of risk
hazards
and disasters? And what are the potential consequences or benefits that could come with conveying the concept of vulnerability to policy and decision makers? [vulnerability
disasters
political ecology
discourse
agency]
Disaster Vulnerability in Anthropological Perspective
There is a certain nervous excitement—an unnerving doubt—that comes over an anthropologist when they encounter well-documented practices that
from their observations
do not conform to the ways they have been documented. This dossier on changing practices of Andean cooperation and reciprocity is the product of several ethnographers confronting particular lapses in correspondences among practice
representation
and discourse. In this short introduction
I provide a succinct orientation to the problem(s) of cooperation and reciprocity in the Andes
followed by a brief account of some of the ethnographic encounters that provoked the dossier. This includes a description of the important role of academic networks in the processes of research
theorizing
and reflection. I follow this by introducing each of the contributions to this issue and conclude by pointing to some of the key cross-cutting themes that emerge from the collection. Each of these pieces speaks to the others while engaging in multiple ongoing conversations with the past
and while I present some indication of these themes and conversations
this overview is by no means exhaustive.
Introduction: Twenty-First Century Dynamics of Cooperation and Reciprocity in the Andes
Cooperative labor parties known throughout the Andes as mingas
although outwardly appearing to be the same cultural institution
are practiced quite differently and with varying meanings in different socioeconomic contexts. This article discusses how minga cooperation came to exhibit contrasting
yet intimately related
patterns of practice and social relationships in both a displaced
disaster-affected village and a disaster-induced resettlement. It describes actors in these groups appealing to ostensibly common repertoires of shared meaning and culture
while organizing themselves in distinct ways in order to access and control scarce resources. In one village
minga participation is largely sustained through traditional practices of reciprocity
while in the other they are maintained through new institutional strategies. In the former
mingas are mobilized to compete with other villages for scarce resources; in the latter
minga participants compete with one another.
Reciprocity and Vernacular Statecraft: Andean Cooperation in Post-disaster Highland Ecuador
A.J.
Faas
Department of Anthropology
University of South Florida